In intercultural exchange, immaterial elements of culture (values, codes of behaviour, traditions and beliefs, etc.) give birth to major problems: they produce differences that are invisible but engender cultural misunderstandings. These usually arise through verbal expression, but they are often hidden in a glance, a silence, a simple gesture which, despite its ordinary appearance, may be the cause of a disturbing feeling for other persons. Cultural misunderstandings may have a tremendous impact on services dedicated to migrants' psychological and physical health. They add further obstacles to migrants' psychosocial conditions and they make the expression and understanding of their needs more difficult. This is dramatically true in border areas highly exposed to migration flows. An urgent intervention requires a rapid and clear identification of their problems. The unsafe conditions of their long journey and their first and distressing confrontation with diversity, as well as their mental bewilderment, or even anxiety and hostility, all are obstacles to an intercultural communication process. In such critical contexts, intercultural communication faces further challenges, as shown by the real case of a cultural misunderstanding with a young Nigerien migrant, in the small Italian island of Lampedusa in 2011. This case also gives the opportunity to introduce a wider and more integrated approach on how to manage migration crises. This approach aims at considering both migrants' psycho-physical conditions and their cultural elements rooted in their behaviors. They need to be acknowledged and addressed before reaching a deep mutual understanding and providing a suitable answer to their needs.

Processus interculturels dans les zones frontalières exposées aux flux migratoires : malentendus culturels et urgence

Vigneri F;
2015-01-01

Abstract

In intercultural exchange, immaterial elements of culture (values, codes of behaviour, traditions and beliefs, etc.) give birth to major problems: they produce differences that are invisible but engender cultural misunderstandings. These usually arise through verbal expression, but they are often hidden in a glance, a silence, a simple gesture which, despite its ordinary appearance, may be the cause of a disturbing feeling for other persons. Cultural misunderstandings may have a tremendous impact on services dedicated to migrants' psychological and physical health. They add further obstacles to migrants' psychosocial conditions and they make the expression and understanding of their needs more difficult. This is dramatically true in border areas highly exposed to migration flows. An urgent intervention requires a rapid and clear identification of their problems. The unsafe conditions of their long journey and their first and distressing confrontation with diversity, as well as their mental bewilderment, or even anxiety and hostility, all are obstacles to an intercultural communication process. In such critical contexts, intercultural communication faces further challenges, as shown by the real case of a cultural misunderstanding with a young Nigerien migrant, in the small Italian island of Lampedusa in 2011. This case also gives the opportunity to introduce a wider and more integrated approach on how to manage migration crises. This approach aims at considering both migrants' psycho-physical conditions and their cultural elements rooted in their behaviors. They need to be acknowledged and addressed before reaching a deep mutual understanding and providing a suitable answer to their needs.
2015
Dans l'échange interculturel, les éléments immatériels de la culture (valeurs, codes de comportement, traditions, croyances, etc.) posent de sérieux problèmes : les différences qu'ils engendrent sont invisibles et génèrent des malentendus culturels. Ceux-ci se manifestent dans l'expression orale, mais ils se cachent souvent dans un regard, un silence, un geste banal en apparence, mais susceptible de susciter un état de gêne chez autrui. Les malentendus culturels constituent un problème majeur dans les services d'assistance psycho-médicale aux migrants, car ils s'ajoutent à d'autres facteurs d'ordre psycho-social, compliquant l'annonce et la compréhension de leur malaise. C'est dramatiquement vrai dans les zones frontalières exposées aux flux migratoires. L'urgence d'une identification claire et rapide des besoins psycho-physiques des migrants, les conditions précaires de la " traversée ", le traumatisme émotionnel de leur plongée dans la diversité et leur état de confusion mentale, voire d'anxiété et d'agressivité, sont tous des obstacles qui risquent de compromettre le processus de communication interculturelle. Les contextes d'urgence posent des défis de communication additionnels. Le cas concret d'un malentendu culturel avec un jeune migrant nigérien arrivé dans la petite île italienne de Lampedusa en 2011 le confirme. Ce cas permet de proposer une approche plus ample et intégrée du phénomène de la crise migratoire. Cette approche est attentive à l'état psycho-physique du migrant et aux éléments culturels dont il est porteur. Il faut les reconnaître et les accepter pour parvenir à une compréhension mutuelle approfondie et apporter une réponse adaptée aux besoins des migrants.
Malentendus culturels
Migrations
Lampedusa
File in questo prodotto:
Non ci sono file associati a questo prodotto.

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12606/12021
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
social impact